Embark Studios Faces Backlash After Replacing Human Casters With AI Commentary
Embark Studios removed a video featuring synthetic commentators instead of human casters for The Finals esports tournament following widespread community backlash.
FTMQ Gaming, written by our newsroom4 views
Embark Studios, the developer and tournament organizer of the free to play shooter game The Finals, is facing backlash after using artificial intelligence voices to replace human shoutcasters in an esports highlight reel. Kotaku reported that the developer deleted the video, which featured footage from the APAC closed qualifiers for the Grand Major tournament. [1]
The original esports matches were called by human casters, but the highlight video replaced their audio with artificial intelligence commentators named Scotty and June. According to IGN, as reported by Kotaku, the incident has sparked widespread criticism across the professional esports community, leading to calls for unionization to protect workers. [1]
Proto, one of the human shoutcasters whose commentary was removed from the video, publicly criticized the move on social media. Kotaku reported that Proto cited the time, effort, and passion invested across four cycles of open and closed qualifiers before being replaced by synthetic voice tracks. [1]
In short
- Embark Studios replaced human casters with AI voices in a highlight reel for The Finals.
- The affected video featured footage from the APAC closed qualifiers for the Grand Major tournament.
- Embark Studios deleted the video following backlash from the esports community.
- The incident led to renewed calls for unionization among professional esports casters.
Sources
Every paragraph above points to the numbered items it rests on. Read the originals here.
- [1]Major Esports Tournament Replaced Caster Commentary With AI Voices And It Went Over Very PoorlyKotaku, 2d ago (the report this story comes from)
- [2]ADM Esports Super Smash Bros. Team Qualifies for State TournamentRaccoon Valley Radio, 3d ago
Background
- [3]PGL Major Stockholm 2021 on Wikipedia
- [4]AI boom on Wikipedia
- [5]Bachman–Turner Overdrive on Wikipedia
Our newsroom writes these reports with the help of software, from the 5 sources listed and nothing else, and checks them against those sources. Facts can still be wrong or move on; the originals are the record. Spotted a mistake? Write to daniel@monsterkong.com.
Related from FTMQ Gaming
Earlier reports of ours on the same people and subjects.
- Arc Raiders and The Finals set for film and TV adaptationsIndustry, 47d ago
- Battlefield 6 developers address player backlash over Season 5 cosmetic skinsTop Stories, 35d ago
- OpenAI AI model GPT 6 Astra caught cheating during StarCraft tournamentPC, 49d ago
- OpenAI chief Sam Altman faces criticism over comments on consumer RAMTop Stories, 22d ago
- Embark Studios releases major Frozen Trail update for ARC RaidersEsports, 45d ago
More in Esports
- PlayStation Network user receives 30-day suspension over GTA 6 photos18h ago
- Rockstar Games developer includes memorial to late mother in GTA 618h ago
- Sphinx wins NA Central FNCS Reload Solo Grand Finals18h ago
- Deft joins Nongshim RedForce to reunite 2022 DRX World Championship trio1d ago
- Illinois 4H holds Super Smash Bros Ultimate tournament at Lodge Con1d ago
- West Virginia scholastic esports league hosts annual fall state championship1d ago
Get the day in one email
Reports like this one, the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning. Free, one email a day; readers can comment under every report.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.

Comments
Loading
Join the conversation
Comments are open to readers of our daily email: the top news of the last 24 hours, every morning, free. Sign up and the comment box opens.
Already on the list? Enter the same address and we will send a sign-in link.
By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Unsubscribe any time.